Ok... So I talked Jake Martin with the ticket office and he told me that it was marked down that I wanted paper tickets versus the card. I informed him that I didn't and that several others online had said the same thing. He said he would talk to the higher ups to see if there was some glitch in the system.
Furthermore, the rough estimation he gave me of paper tickets to the card was 70/30. That it was overwhelmingly paper tickets and many there in the ticket office thought it was strange. Unfortunately because they get the tickets from a third party you won't be able to get anything other than what you have. He said they will look to see what they can do to make sure there are no future errors etc.
On a side note, I made the recommendation that if they do cards they do one sheet of home tickets as a collector's item/memorabilia (they will not be functional at all). That way you can have the durability and functionality of the card but for those who like to have the paper ticket for memory sake can have it without it being damaged, etc. He really liked the idea and said that he would pass that on and hopefully make more options for the fans. For those who like this idea, you could re-emphasize the idea so that they do make it an option.