Antisemitism can't be ignored

Global Jewish population at 15.8 million, still below pre-Holocaust levels, new data shows

Not exactly antisemitism related but interesting for contrast on how much hate there is for a small population.

1 Like

That was an interesting read on the historical context of the anti Jewish hate.

Oddly enough it reminds me of the “Wolf in the Fold” episode on star trek TOS…

Yes, there is something here. Something terrible. I feel its presence. Fear, anger, hatred. Anger feeds the flame. Oh! Oh! There is evil here. Monstrous, terrible evil. Consuming hunger. Hatred of all that lives. Hatred of women [Jews]. A hunger that never dies. It is strong, overpowering. An ancient terror. It has a name. Beratis, Kesla, Redjac! Devouring all life, all light. A hunger that will never die! Redjac! Redjac!

That episode was written by one Robert Bloch, who “was born to parents of German-Jewish descent. While his parents were of Jewish heritage, they were not orthodox, and the family was described as culturally Jewish rather than religious.”

1 Like

So…do these numbers include those that identify as “culturally Jewish” or
only those that actively practice the faith ?

Not sure if I ever saw that episode. As to your other question, I don’t know how they figured their methodology.

I would say that I think the majority of people who are more “culturally Jewish” rather than actively practice would answer “Jewish” when asked about their religion so it likely is a count of both.

Attacks against Jews can start in most cases because you are by name identified as being Jewish. This is how EFFED up this is.

No what’s effed up is it doesn’t even need to be a name, it could be a look and it very well could be a misidentification of someone as “looking Jewish” or “sounding Jewish”, etc.

Unfortunately that isn’t something that just happens with antisemitism, any type of bigotry can come from that type of misidentification through stereotypes.

And, of course, sometimes it’s not antisemitism but simply being for human decency.

So, ramming Jews with your car, setting Jews on fire in Colorado, shooting Jews in DC, setting synagogues on fire, painting swastikas on temple doors is justified??? GTFOH

1 Like

Today is Yom Hashoa (Holocaust Remembrance Day)

Today, as we remember the Holocaust, it’s worth pointing out that the Jewish population is only now approaching pre-Holocaust numbers.

• 1939: 16.6 million
• 1945: 11 million
• 2025: 15.8 million

During the Holocaust: ~34% of the global Jewish population systematically exterminated.

Never forget!

2 Likes

Are you replying to me, and if so, where in my list did I say or even imply, any of that?

Two bad things can be true at once, in case you weren’t aware.

@TheMandell You’re using an awful incident from Israeli forces to justify antisemetic attacks on Jews in the USA or other countries?

By saying, hey sometimes its not antisemitism but its about human decency but not giving specific incidents of where it wasn’t antisemitism is actually you saying hey Jews deserve it.

I’ve been pretty intentional about posting incidents that were clearly antisemetic, and not just people who were anti-war or outraged at Israeli government/military actions. I did that intentionally so there would be no confusion. Unfortunately, you don’t see it that way. At least, in the way you framed your post you do not see it that way. You basically are blaming all Jews in the diaspora for actions of Israel that they have no control, vote, or say about and may even condemn themselves.

Its in the context, you didn’t have to specifically say it. However, here’s an opportunity, explain yourself…

what point were you making in a thread about antisemitism by posting about an awful incident from Israel and saying “hey sometimes it isn’t about antisemitism”? Because it sure seems like you’re saying Jews are bad.

1 Like

[[quote=“Duce630, post:1699, topic:57681, full:true”]

@TheMandell You’re using an awful incident from Israeli forces to justify antisemetic attacks on Jews in the USA or other countries?

[/quote]

No, I am not. You read something into my post that is clearly not there. That’s on you, not me.

Israel has and continues to do horrible things. That’s a fact. Hiding behind antisemitism attacks to ignore or justify wrongdoing isn’t a strategy that should be attempted but is on a regular basis here.

That’s my point.

1 Like

Bull. No one has done that here. That is you reading something that is not there.

So, was still mulling this over and came across this figure of “over 20 million.”
Still a very small number. All depends on who is doing the counting and the methodology being used. This is not a refutation or challenge to what’s been
posted, but more a statement of the inherent problems in all the counting
data involving people. Totally happy with the 15 million claim; just a little
fascinated how we humans struggle with “counting”.

New terms (to me) of “Enlarged Population”, “Connected”, “law of return” and
aforementioned “culturally Jewish”. So range is less than 15 million or 15.8 to 25.5 million.

AI “slop”

  • Enlarged Population: If including individuals with partial Jewish heritage (defined by “right of return” laws), the population reaches over 20 million.
  • Historical Trends: The Jewish population in Europe has declined to roughly 1.3 million.

World Population ReviewWorld Population Review +

Non AI…

The number of Jews worldwide rises to 18 million if the “connected” Jewish population is added. “Connected” Jews includes those who say they are partly Jewish or that have Jewish backgrounds from at least one Jewish parent. The number rises to 21 million if the “enlarged” Jewish population. This includes those who say they have Jewish backgrounds but no Jewish parents and all non-Jewish household members who live with Jews. If you throw in people eligible for Israeli citizenship under Israel’s Law of Return — defined as anyone with at least one Jewish grandparent, and who does not profess any other religion — the number rises to 25.5 million. The number of Jews would shrink below 15 million if a tighter definition — such as an unbroken line of matrilineal Jewish descent — were imposed. [Source: Wikipedia, 2024]

The definition of a Jew is hotly contested issue in Israel. Traditionally, children of Jewish mothers have been recognized as Jewish. Conservative Jews insist that this is not enough: a true Jew is someone who keeps Jewish law and obeys the commandments. "Whoever saves a single Jew,” reads the Babylonian Talmud. "Scripture ascribes it to him as though he had saved an entire world.”

Some groups also accept children of Jewish fathers as Jewish. American reformed Judaism recognizes patrilineal descent. The State of Israel grants citizenship under the law of return to people with a single Jewish grandparent. Conservative Jews Chas Chabadniks accept only the Talmudic rule that a Jew is anyone born to a Jewish mother, or someone who has undergone an Orthodox conversion and agreed to keep all 613 Jewish laws. A Jew traditionally can’t lose his or her technical ‘status’ of being a Jew by adopting another faith, but they do lose the religious element of their Jewish identity. Someone who isn’t born a Jew can convert to Judaism, but it is not easy to do so."

1 Like

Yes I was replying to you. Since you posted this in the anti-Semitism thread it definitely sounded to me like you were justifying anti-Semitic attacks.

Also yes, both are wrong.

2 Likes

Interesting. I do disagree with some of the items, but as we like to say, you can put 3 Jewish people in a room and have 4 different opinions. :rofl::rofl:

Converting to Reform Judaism isn’t THAT hard.

One of my aunts did it.

It’s an 18 month to 2 year process.

While Judaism doesn’t appear to proselytize the way that a lot of other religions do, it DOES accept converts.

Zelensky signs a tough anti-Semitism law in Ukraine.

The level of difficulty kinda depends on who is doing the conversion. A reform conversion will be “easier” than from a Conservative Rabbi, which could be “easier” than from an Orthodox Rabbi.

There are some Orthodox Jews that do not recognize somebody who did not go through an Orthodox conversion to be Jewish. It’s nuts.

You’re right about your last point. We don’t recruit, but we make darn sure you want to do it and for the right reasons. Some Rabbis won’t do it if the reason is solely for marriage…or if you’re doing it for the jokes (Seinfeld reference)

1 Like