I am replying to I4Ts post because I am in pretty much in agreement on his thoughts here, I think.
I was heavily involved with the scouts from the cubs and serving until my late 20s as an Assistant Scoutmaster. A few more years after that in name only.
I am obviously for those that know me here on the liberal side of the spectrum, not making this political, because the demise to scouting might seem politically it is much greater than that. It might be greatly cultural but much broader cultural elements than all the current woke talk.
The demise started a long time ago. Everything that the scouts did to combat their demise actually made things worse.
My main point to begin with his scouts was never only supposed to be about the outdoors and those badges it has always been about learning a set of values as exemplified in the Scout Oath, Law, Motto & Slogan.
That is what counts, that is the only thing that counts. If you don’t learn that then all those skill badges on the road to Eagle men nothing.
I believe this learning was supposed to be boys alone learning from decent men. Men, not women. So the first problem was female scoutmasters.
By the way, there have always been women involved in Boy Scouts of America but the singularity of the scoutmaster and assistant scoutmaster roles I have a problem with.
The scouts purposely removed time constraints on the road to Eagle. The problem with this is the young men don’t stay around to teacher the younger boys.
The scouts were not quick enough to get rid of creepy people. The scouts were not quick enough to have simple rules in place the a lone adult should be left a lone with a lone boy.
They didn’t think of good ways to keep young men engaged in a changing world. They tried, but failed at every turn.
The scouts have been selling land off but the hundreds of thousands of acres, including my beloved camp in upstate New York and many more around the country.
I could write for another hour. It is pitiful.