First and foremost, I want to make it clear that this isn’t a topic to completely s**t on Dana. He came to UH, and it didn’t work out. No matter what anyone says about Dana, he got UH a championship appearance and sent multiple guys to the big leagues.
That being said……
What I think can be universally agreed on is that Dana Holgorsen did a poor job of recruiting Quarterbacks in preparation of UH joining the Big 12. Dana Holgorsen was given both D’Eriq King and Clayton Tune (one of which transferred) by the previous staff.
Dana brought in Donovan Smith, who struggles to this day with consistency from Texas Tech. If Donovan was a stellar QB, he would’ve had no reason to transfer from Tech. Dana grabbed him thinking his experience against Big 12 teams would help. It didn’t, and Donovan’s consistency is still an issue under CWF.
Uli Ale, another Dana recruit, clearly is lacking something to not get any shots at QB so far. Ale was set to backup Donovan under the Dana staff, but clearly things have changed.
Zeon Chriss is a Willie Fritz transfer, who was brought in 1 month after Fritz took the job, most likely to add depth to an already struggling QB lineup.
Now I’m not blaming everything on our QBs, but CWF is essentially playing with the cards he has. Simply put - We do not have a good lineup of QBs for a consistent highpower offense. I think Willie hoped that Donovan, a 4th year Power 5 quarterback, would be able to fix his issues by now. He hasn’t, unfortunately.
It’s not the head coach’s job to hope - it’s his job to evaluate, prepare and choose wisely. It’s not the previous coach’s fault that the new guy hasn’t done that.
If the QB performance isn’t due to an injury, then his regression is 100% on the new staff.
Fair assessment. I remember Holgorsen chatting with Smith after the OT loss at Tech. It looked like Holgorsen was telling Smith to give him a call if he decided to transfer at the end of the year.
As for Ale, there must be a reason he’s third string. May not fit the offense, may have already said he’s leaving. I won’t rule out coaching error since nobody is perfect.
You cannot develop a QB, who has lacked consistency his entire college career and was injured majority of the off season, into a draft pick in less than a year.
He was better last year than this year, and if the new coaches didn’t build on that, then they either chose the wrong guy or they just don’t know how to get it done.
If you can’t own it, you can’t fix it. Blaming the previous coach is just super-weak, and I’m sure Fritz doesn’t see it that way. We shouldn’t either.
We are 4 games in, and even with the very simple offensive scheme we are running, Donovan is still struggling with reads, pocket pressure, and balance issues, all of which should not be happening as frequently as they are for a 4th year Power 5 QB.
What about the guy he recruited to transfer? Should he not be expected to develop his own guy to contribute?
You just can’t point at the previous staff when you’ve had 9 months to get someone ready to compete.
These guys are not performing anywhere close to their potential. That’s far more concerning than the previous guy’s recruiting. Fix that problem and we’re at least competitive.
We lost a lot of weapons DS had on offense from last season. New offense too. But just cause someone transfers from one program doesn’t mean they couldn’t cut it there. Will Howard went from KSU to tOsu. Dana did do a bad job of recruiting but it’s not like these transfers are playing football for their first time in their lives. They have been in other programs, watch videos, study, learn plays…etc.
I’m not trying to argue with you fellow coog. I’m just trying to figure out the inconsistency too. I don’t think it’s broken down by game. Let’s just see how DS ends up looking at the end of this season v last season. And I hope we have some high scoring games that will skew his stats this season…
Again, Fritz chose him as the starter. Fritz has chosen to keep playing him while not adjusting the offense.
Whining about recruiting instead of addressing the current issues doesn’t make sense.
The problem is that he doesn’t have the QB to run HIS system and he hasn’t adjusted for the talent he does have at all. Either figure out how to make it work with the first guy or move on to the next one - it’s very simple.
You say you’re focused on Smith’s inconsistency, but the thread title indicates this is just another Dana whine.
If Fritz is really opening the job up, then he’s doing the right thing. The problem is that he’s doing it too late. Our problems on offense have been obvious and consistent since Game 1.
And they’ll continue unless changes are made both in preparation and personnel. You have to go back pretty far in our history to find a 4-game stretch with this level of offensive futility. Our players aren’t THAT bad.
DS was injured and missed the entire spring practice, which was not helpful. When he has time to throw, no one is open. When he does not have time to throw, he is running for his life. It’s easy to blame the QB but this is a bad (as in lacking talent, size and speed) football team. The defense is passable, but the offense and special teams are lacking.
CWF openly admitted he refused to watch game film of our team last season…bad move.
Im no DH apologist…but this is NOT on Dana…the secind CWF took over…it was HIS ROSTER. If he didn’t like it, he had the Transfer Portal + NIL at his disposal.
If he didn’t do a deep analysis on HIS OWN roster…that’s on CWF.
Listen to his interviews…he mentions he purposely did NOT watch us last season bc he wanted no bias with HIS roster.